Final Tribal Council

[Mary Sartain]

Well so far I still have no reason to vote for either one of you, since neither of you actually answered my first question. Just one final question though. Ami, why did you guys vote me out? (I know Kathy had nothing to do with it, she just went along with the crowd, as she always had, because she had no good gameplay of her own). Just curious.

[Jeff Probst]

Dec 29, 2008 16:35:25 GMT -5 Jonathan Penner said:

Well, I've heard enough to know my vote.

Can we send our votes in now, Jeff?

Yes. Once you guys know who you are voting for send me your votes by pm please.

[Ami Cusack]

Well so far I still have no reason to vote for either one of you, since neither of you actually answered my first question. Just one final question though. Ami, why did you guys vote me out? (I know Kathy had nothing to do with it, she just went along with the crowd, as she always had, because she had no good gameplay of her own). Just curious.

Mary, I voted for you because you were the last one from your original tribe, being that you were the next to go. And, I had alot of respect for you as a player!

You won a challenge, and you were smart at trying to change the game. I know you were doing your best to try and survive, and change the votes if you could. You were a good player, and that was very respectable.

[Yau-Man Chan]

Well, congratulations to you two. Honestly, I still haven't decided on who to vote for. This is gonna be tough because I think my original questions were taken in a different way.

So here are my new questions:

Ami - Who from the real Survivor do you think would fit your personality in this game and why? Please be truthful. Also, give three adjectives about yourself and Kathy.

Kathy - If you have the choice, who would you bring among the fans (Mikey B, Natalie, Mary, and Erik) with you for the Final Tribal Council? Also, give three adjectives about yourself and Ami.

Good luck!

[Kathy Sleckman]

"Kathy: Why do you think you should get my vote? You offered to work with me but it seems like you didn't.
Why do you think people would vote for Ami over you?"

I would hope you and everyone else would vote for me over Ami because I had a harder road to go and respect that I had to work harder because I was at the bottom of that five person alliance and worked myself up to a 3 person alliance which got me where I am now. We never had a real chance to work together - you were voted out while part of the other team.

Also compare each person on the jury with a real survivor, who had similar gameplay or strategy, and why you said they were similar.


Mikey B - You actually remind me of the other Mikey B! A good player who didn't have a chance to play the game as much as he would have liked.

Natalie - Corinne from Gabon. You were a tough competitor and not afraid to say what you thought.

Mary - Heidi from Africa. That is not a compliment.

Jonny Fairplay - As you pointed out, I don't know you very well so I'll just pick a strong player who didn't make it to the end - Robert "General" DeCanio from Marquesas.

Cirie - Kim Johnson from Africa. You were very under the radar.

Eliza - Amanda from China. A strong woman.

Erik- Colby from Australia. A strong, good hearted player.

Jonathan- I think you are most like Jonathan. You played a strong game like he did.

James - You remind me of Ace. You thought you had control of everything but you really didn't.

Yau Man - Yau-Man, you remind me of Yau-Man. He won a few challenges and he was nice to everyone. Everybody's friend.

[Kathy Sleckman]

"Kathy - If you have the choice, who would you bring among the fans (Mikey B, Natalie, Mary, and Erik) with you for the Final Tribal Council? Also, give three adjectives about yourself and Ami."

Probably Natalie. She played the strongest game, I thought, of the other fans.

Me: Loyal. Decisive. Thick skin.
Ami: Emotional. Loyal. Paranoid.

[Eliza Orlins]

Ami, was our alliance genuine? Were you intending to go all the way with me like you said? What did that mean? Or were you staying with Kathy and Yau-Man? Be honest please



Now I have a question for both (courtesy of Nemle22):


Luck - Honesty - Manipulation - Communication - Numbers - Personality - Laziness - Association - Trust - Activeness


I believe that these are the 10 biggest factors to an ORG. Whether it's the reason you win...or the reason you lose. In a positive way...or a negative one. At least one of these is ALWAYS attached to the reason.

I want both of you to do 2 things for me. First, list all Jurors and tell me which of those 10 factors sent them home...and why it did. Secondly, I want both of you to give me an example of how each factor got you here in the F2.

[James Clement]

James - You remind me of Ace. You thought you had control of everything but you really didn't.

OK LET ME JUST SAY ONE THING: I DID NOT think I was in control. Penner and Yau Man clearly RAN everything and you just went along with it- I tried to do something to stop this control, and unfortunately I couldn't. At least I didn't sit back and let others run the show.

[Natalie Bolton]

haha. I am like Corinne, Kathy.

And maybe i should be a juror just like Corinne was...completely biased and cruel. Sounds good to me!


Ami- Reading what you say makes me want to vomit. I have no questions for you because i am sick of reading what you type, so please don't reply to this so i don't have to listen to you anymore. You played a game just like Ami did. You tried to take full control, lied to every one, and just acted like a complete b*tch! Watching you advance further in the game made me want to kill myself.



Kathy-People keep blaming you for coasting. When really, I dont see why they are doing that! Are people honestly forgetting how the picking order was? Do people honestly forget watching every single fan except for you get picked off? What else could you have done? Displaying yourself as a threat would've gotten you voted off with the rest of the fans. You did what you had to do to get by. Yeah, you caused me getting voted off, and completely turned on whatever alliance you made on me. However, I can't blame you for it! Because you had to do whatever you could to get farther in the game. Congratulations, you did it. That's why you're getting my vote tonight.


Ami, please don't even talk about this in this thread. I don't want to ever talk to you again. K. Thanks. Bye.

[Kathy Sleckman]

Thank you, Natalie. I really appreciate that. At least I'm getting one vote!

[Kathy Sleckman]

Mikey B - Numbers. As all of the fans except me found, numbers were what killed them.

Natalie - Numbers.

Mary - Numbers.

Jonny Fairplay - Activeness. Because you were so active people saw you as a threat.

Cirie - Activeness. The opposite of fairplay. Not active enough so they got rid of you - at least that's what I was told. I wasn't there so it's hard for me to say.

Eliza - Numbers and luck. It was very unlucky of you to be separated from Ami at the TC where you were voted out. We had the numbers and Ami wasn't there to fight for you.

Erik- Numbers both times.

Jonathan - Activeness. You were very active and perceived as a threat which is why people turned on you.

James - Personality. I never trusted you all that much, James - your personality made it clear to me that I was an outsider to you.

Yau Man - Personality did you in, too, Yau-Man but for a different reason. You were too nice to take to the Final 2.

As for me...

Luck - Well, apparently it was luck that Erik gave me immunity so that's one way luck helped me. There was also a challenge early on that I won that was pure luck.

Honesty - I was completely honest and upfront with Yau-Man and Ami. I told them everything I learned to gain their trust.

Manipulation - I manipulated people in that first vote when I flipped on the fans. I also manipulated Jonathan a little bit as I worked him while keeping my alliance with Ami and Yau-Man. If for some reason he made it to the end, I felt confident he'd pick me.

Communication - I did a good job communicating to Ami, Yau-Man and Jonathan my thoughts and plans for the game.

Numbers - I created a situation where my alliance had the numbers and that lead to the downfall of the rest of the fans.

Personality - I think my friendly personality lead Yau-Man and Ami to trust and respect me and got me to the end.

Laziness - Well, a lack of laziness got me to the end. I worked hard every step of the way to keep my alliance together and make sure I was not on the chopping block.

Association - I associated myself with a strong alliance that got me to the end.

Trust - I trusted Ami, Yau-Man, Jonathan and James to keep their word and stick with our Final Five alliance. It was a big gamble, but it worked.

Activeness - I was always active and I am hoping jurors will respect that and vote for me.


"Ami, was our alliance genuine? Were you intending to go all the way with me like you said? What did that mean? Or were you staying with Kathy and Yau-Man? Be honest please"

I'd really like to hear the answer to this one, too, since Ami promised me that we were final two to the end.

[Jonathan Penner]

Actually Kathy, your name came up from Fairplay as the next boot and I did not want you voted out so I pleaded to Erik and Cirie to give you immunity.
It may have been luck that they did though...

[Mary Sartain]

Dec 29, 2008 21:25:15 GMT -5 Kathy Sleckman said:

"
Mary - Heidi from Africa. That is not a compliment.

Hmm don't remember a Heidi in Africa. Looks like another thing that you have no clue about.

[Eliza Orlins]

Dec 29, 2008 23:42:33 GMT -5 Mary Sartain said:

Dec 29, 2008 21:25:15 GMT -5 Kathy Sleckman said:

"
Mary - Heidi from Africa. That is not a compliment.

Hmm don't remember a Heidi in Africa. Looks like another thing that you have no clue about.

Lol

And I don't understand Kathy. How do you base your decision if a person is active or inactive? Would you call a person that self-voted at least twice and maybe didn't do a challenge active?

[James Clement]

Um Kathy...you are clearly clueless about everything, and it is pathetic. I can't vote for anyone that doesn't know a thing about anything. Sorry.